While I didn’t quite manage to top last year’s total, I still read 157 books in 2025, which is still a lot! Running a bookstore is both a help and a hindrance in this regard, as it allows me to discover interesting new titles but also sometimes keeps me too busy to read as much as I’d like. Nevertheless, I consumed some fantastic titles this year, which I now present in the order I read them:


First-Time Caller & And Now, Back to You
The first installment in this series, First-Time Caller, rightfully enjoyed quite a bit of popularity early in the year. Billed as being reminiscent of Sleepless in Seattle, I’m happy to report that it delivers on all of the classic rom-com vibes you could want and features a cast of lovable characters, the majority of which make appearances in the upcoming sequel, And Now, Back to You. I enjoyed the latter just as much, and the snowed-in weather people vibes make for an excellent post-Christmas winter read.

The Once and Future Witches
If there’s a recurring theme of the book club I run at the bookstore, it’s “books Anna’s been meaning to read for ages,” and this Alex E. Harrow classic was the first of such books to make the OH Literary Society selection this year. Simultaneously a story of three very different sisters, a historical account of the struggle for women’s rights, and an atmospheric fantasy, Harrow manages to weave all these various threads together into a very satisfying tome.

A Memory of Light
This February I finished the three year, five month, and six day journey to read the entire Wheel of Time series, which will go down as one of my absolute favorites. It is truly mind-boggling how expansive and well-detailed the world building is, and while I appreciated the main chosen-one plot I still maintain that it’s the B, C, D, and even E plots that truly make this series so interesting. Add to that the multi-faceted magic system, and the result is a series I’m sure I will return to again and again. The Wheel of Time turns indeed.

Good Dirt
I greatly enjoyed Wilkerson’s debut Black Cake, but there’s a marked development in her follow-up Good Dirt, which released early this year. Focusing on an affluent Black family, their treasured family heirloom, and a tragic incident that marked them all, Wilkerson’s grasp of character and story threads was even more impressive on her second go-around. I was particularly struck by how an object created through an ancestor’s forced labor could become a treasured item, how creativity in the face of suffering can impact future generations, and how history is constantly being written.

North Woods
Another OH Lit Society selection, this was perhaps my favorite book club book of the year. Starting in the colonial era and moving forward through time, a rotating cast of characters pass through the same home in the New England woods. In some ways reading like a collection of short stories, I was particularly struck by how each entry informed and referred back to each other and the way the language evolved over time. Beautifully written and deeply affecting, I’m sure this will go down in the Lit Society Hall of Fame and be a tough act to beat.


A Death on Corfu & A Murder in Marylebone
I love me a historical mystery, especially if it blends mystery and romance and features an engaging main character, which is certainly the case for this new series from Emily Sullivan. Widow Minnie Harper has been living on Corfu with her two children when tetchy and famous (and famously tetchy!) mystery author Stephen Dorian moves in next door. She finds herself doing some typing work for him, and after a young maid is murdered the two reluctantly teamed up to investigate. Its sequel, A Murder in Marylebone, is just as excellent, and finds Minnie back in London and confronting her past. Minnie’s investigative mind and her chemistry with Dorian make this a promising addition to the genre.

Miss Austen
Jane Austen’s sister Cassandra quite famously burned a number of her letters after her death in order to protect her legacy, and it’s this historical fact that serves as the jumping-off point for this novel about the family behind the beloved author. We’ll never know what those letters contained, but it’s interesting to imagine, which Hornby does with the charm, scathing wit, and warmth the author is known for in her books.

Greenteeth
Jenny Greenteeth is an eons-old lake monster who’s spent that time largely minding her own business, protecting her lake and staying far away from the humans who fear her needle-sharp teeth. But when one of those humans is thrown into the aforementioned lake on suspicion of witchcraft, Jenny’s policy of non-interference is shattered and she finds herself assisting in the defeat of a sinister evil. Borrowing heavily from English folklore, particularly Arthurian tales, I absolutely fell in love with Jenny and her no-nonsense, curious voice.

Birnam Wood
If you like your fiction Shakespearean in its examination of human nature, then have I got a book for you. Not-for-profit, guerrilla environmental group Birnam Wood is given an opportunity beyond their wildest dreams: A whole lot of money and permission to use a large swath of land in the New Zealand countryside. The catch? It’s almost definitely certainly a coverup for a tech billionaire’s less-than-legal activities, whose shades of shadiness are expertly revealed as the novel goes on. Catton is a master of layers (which she proved in her Booker Prize-winning The Luminaries), and the way she presents an event then loops back to show the reader how it was arrived at, only to leave you with a cliffhanger at the very end, is both satisfying and infuriating in equal measure. Another OH Lit Society Hall of Famer!

Swordheart
I really really love T. Kingfisher’s brand of cozy, clever, and oft-fairytale inspired fantasy, and while I read several of her works this year it’s Swordheart that takes the top spot for me. Reduced down to its most basic form the premise is basically just this: he’s a ten, but he’s an immortal warrior trapped in a sword. Do with this information what you will, but I highly recommend you pick up this endearing and cozy romantasy. (P.S. I did also manage to get my grubby little hands on an advance copy of its sequel, Daggerbound, but as publication is so far out it doesn’t even have a cover design yet [that’s correct, this is a brag], I chose not to include it in the title entry. But I promise it’s just as good!)



The Emily Wilde Series
Speaking of the folklore and fairy-tale inspired (it’s almost like I have a favorite fantasy subgenre), this historically-set series follows a professor of faerie kind and her maybe fae prince fellow professor love interest (spoiler alert, he’s definitely a fae prince) as they defeat an evil queen but more importantly, expand the scholarship of the fae realm. Peopled with a fun cast of side characters and told in Emily’s curmudgeonly but endearing voice, I adored this trilogy and also greatly enjoyed Fawcett’s next book, Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter.

Nicked
I have two words for you: medieval heist. Okay, two more words: true story. That’s right, in the 11th century some mercenaries and Catholic clergy, ahem, liberated the bones of Saint Nicholas from modern-day Turkey, where they were said to perform miracles. This was done ostensibly because a monk had a dream that the Saint wanted to move to Italy, but in actuality it was more a desire for a boost in tourism. Nevertheless their actions paved the way for this rollicking and strangely earnest book, which I greatly enjoyed. Just whatever you do, do not look up exactly how the miracles were said to occur if you’re a bit squeamish.

The Lady Darby Mysteries
After absolutely inhaling Huber’s Verity Kent mysteries last year, I decided it was finally time to loop around to her first series, which follows a painter and widow of an anatomist in 1830’s Scotland who discovers a talent for investigating murders. Lady Darby is yet another fully-fleshed and compelling protagonist from Huber, and I greatly enjoyed how she used the not-often portrayed time and place to shine a light on some very interesting historical events. As of writing this I’ve finished all thirteen published books, and I certainly plan on embarking on my advance copy of the fourteenth in the New Year!
Honorable Mentions: Love You a Latke, The Stella and Lyndy Mysteries, The River Has Roots, Martyr!, Great Big Beautiful Life, Big Chief, What Happened in Miss Austen, The Paris Express, And then There Was the One, A Shore Thing, The Rushworth Family Plot, The Celebrants, The Listeners, TheShady Hollow Mysteries, The Wrong Lady Meets Lord Right, The Road to Tender Hearts, Mutual Interest, The Austen Affair, The Other Bennet Sister, Harriet Tubman: Live in Concert, Thistlefoot, Fan Service, Sunk in Love, The Princess Knight, Bog Queen, The Antiquarian’s Object of Desire, The Hounding, Agnes Aubert’s Mystical Cat Shelter, Love is a War Song, The Gales of November, A Matter of Murder, Hemlock & Silver, The Fatal Unpleasantness at Netherfield, The Snow Child, Good Spirits, Nine Goblins











































































































